Take Our HR Skills Assessment to Get a Custom Learning Plan

Firing an Employee

Have you faced your first termination yet? No one likes this part of HR, but conducting them well (and/or teaching your managers to do so) is an important skill. You need to keep your actions legal, ethical and defensible. It’s often difficult to predict how smoothly the process will go, but even the most experienced professionals confirm that a little planning goes a long way in both mitigating risk and making a difficult event go well for all parties involved.

Firing an Employee: Legal vs. Illegal

Most states have “at-will” employment laws in place. This means that an employee is not under contract for a specified period of time with their employer, and the employer retains the right to terminate an employee “at will,” or as they see fit.  Sometimes this is referred to as for “good, bad or no reason at all.”  But even if you are operating under at-will employment, firing people is not simple. In order to protect your company from potential liability and lawsuits, you need to be sure you are acting legally.

Before you recommend a termination, make sure you are acting in a manner consistent with how other employees have been treated. Are men treated the same as women? Are older workers treated similarly to younger workers? Are people of color or with disabilities treated like the rest of the employee population?  Being consistent in when and why you terminate employees plays a big role in not only how your company is seen in general, but also in the number and types of legal claims you’ll need to defend.

This is where a good employee handbook is essential. Do you have the rules of conduct clearly laid out?  Do you have a defined performance management process?  Do you have an acknowledgement page that the employee signs to confirm their understanding of the contents of the handbook? If your answer to any of these questions is no, go to our article on employee handbooks! If you answered yes, then ensure that you are (and have been) following your own policy and commitments to the employee. A lack of compliance with your own policies can be used against you in an Equal Employment Opportunity suit.

Reasons to Fire an Employee

The most common reasons to terminate an employee have their roots in either conduct or performance, but there are many other reasons employment may end. Before you decide to fire an employee, be sure that you have gone through all of the facts in accordance with your internal policies and processes and have considered alternatives before resorting to termination. As a rule, termination should never be a surprise to an employee. They may not want to admit it, but they should see it coming. Basic reasons for firing someone include:

  • Behavior. Policy violations or misconduct.
  • Performance: as the final step in a corrective action process.
  • Job elimination. A division closure, reduction in workforce, or a restructure.
  • Temporary status. A seasonal or temporary assignment concludes.

How to Fire an Employee

Being fired is usually a traumatic event, regardless of cause. Someone is losing their income, and all of the other things that are associated with having employment, involuntarily. It’s when employees feel that they have been treated unfairly or have been degraded or humiliated that they tend to seek legal action. Because of this, it is critical to be prepared, be brief and to the point, and work to keep the employee’s dignity intact at all times.

Step 1: Be straightforward

Begin by advising the person that you have reached the decision to terminate, and tell them why. Don’t leave them wondering why they’ve been summoned to meet with you. Be direct, concise and empathetic. (Note that empathy is not sympathy.)  Ensure you cover the data points that illustrate where they were coached, redirected, or reprimanded along the way that led to this decision to separate.  What is happening and why it’s happening should be very clear to all parties.

Step 2: Listen

Give the employee a chance to explain their understanding of the decision to terminate. Allow them to react. Hear them out.They could be emotional, angry, quiet, aggressive or any other response. Be sure this doesn’t turn into a negotiation: this decision is final.

Step 3: Practical Details

This list will be unique to your company, but here are common items on it:

  • Be sure to collect all company property (a checklist comes in handy here).
  • Remind them of your company’s referral policy (sticking to name, title, and dates of employment is a safe bet).
  • Explain their right to apply for unemployment and the process by which to do so.
  • Advise them that they will receive information on the continuation of health benefits, 401K or pension plans, other insurance and the like by mail.
  • Get their current forwarding address. Often, their personnel file is not updated, so this is critical.

Step 4: The Leavetaking

Explain to them how you would like them to exit the building (they may ask whether or not they will be able to say any final farewells to teammates).  Finally, share with them how you plan to cascade the news to their former team, other internal people, and/or customers. Remember to be respectful and keep the employee’s dignity intact.

What to Do After You Fire an Employee

After the termination has been conducted and you’ve had a chance to exhale, begin the internal communication.

Step 1: Communication

Determine who needs to know. Consider the employee’s workgroup/team, other internal employees, and internal and/or external customers. Deal with each group separately and show sensitivity. Be concise and brief, allow for reactions, and be prepared to address them.

Step 2: Transition the Work

Have a transition plan in place for the employee’s workload. Clearly communicate it to any and all impacted parties, both internally and externally.

Step 3: Document the Meeting

Write a recap of the termination meeting for the person’s file. Note the reason for the termination and the efforts the company made along the way.

Questions You’ve Asked Us About Firing An Employee

Can an employee be fired without warning?
Yes. Termination “for cause” is totally legal, and commonly (but not always) invoked when an egregious infraction has occurred. Businesses can also close plants or offices without warning, if they are a certain size. The Worker Adjustment and Retraining Notification Act of 1988 (WARN) requires that most employers provide 60 calendar days notification to employees facing job loss due to plant closure or mass layoff. If the business has fewer than 100 employees, WARN does not apply.
What qualifies as wrongful termination?
A termination found to be in violation of Equal Employment Opportunity Commission laws is wrongful. Being terminated for of any of these reasons is protected under EEO law: age, disability, equal pay/compensation, genetic information, harassment, national origin, pregnancy, sexual orientation and gender edentity, race/color, religion, sexual garrassment, retaliation, or sex. Good documentation is key in defending your company against an EEO claim.
What does "termination for cause" mean?
Termination for cause means to fire to let go an employee for a sufficient reason. Some appropriate reasons could be theft, harassment, insubordination, or other policy violations. It typically implies that the employee is at fault.
Milly Christmann

Milly Christmann

Milly Christmann is a high energy, operationally oriented talent management leader with extensive expertise in human resources, sales management, service and operations. She is recognized for collaborating with leaders to achieve their business goals by unleashing the power of an engaged workforce. By using process improvement, technology and strong, impassioned people skills as well as by attracting, developing and retaining top talent, Ms. Christmann drives change that matters.

Want to contribute to our HR Encyclopedia?

Posts You Might Like

What is People Management Software?

What is People Management Software?

People management software sounds important, but what exactly does that mean? Does your business need it? What businesses benefit most? All these questions and more are answered as we dive into the fascinating world of people management software and determine what’s best for your company.

Read More »
The Ultimate Guide on How to Manage Employees in a Small Business

The Ultimate Guide on How to Manage Employees in a Small Business

When it comes to running a small business, we know that managing employees is often one of the most difficult tasks. People are complicated, and finding a way to keep your employees happy and productive can be challenging. This article shares specific advice for what you can do in the three phases of the employee lifecycle to get the most out of each employee.

Read More »

Want to join our network of contributing HR professionals?

Scroll to Top

Submit a Question